Chapter 4: Chapter 4: Falling Apart . . . Barely Breathing
First of all, I'm not really into J/MP romance. That being I said, I want you to know that I am reading your story and will continue to read it until you finish. I won't give you an opinion right now, because I prefer to comment it as a whole. I can give you some advice if you don't mind:
1 - Revising: your writing seems to get better at each new chapter, which makes me think you're publishing as soon as you write. While I can relate to the urge, having the text rest for some time is often a good thing. Especially for catching rookie mistakes. I don't know if this is the case, but if it is...
2 - The plot: I know that J/MP stories sometimes lack that aspect. Technically, their relationship is your plot, but you may need something stronger than that. You have plenty of inner conflict, which is good, but you need an outside force as well. With The Centre and The Triumvirate gone you'll have to come up with a new threat.
3 - The endgame: When you first started to write this story, did you see how it ended? Did you have any glimpses? Every time I write a story, fanfiction or otherwise, I always (try to) see the end, or, at the very least, a possible end. Whether the end I write is the end I previously imagined or not isn't the issue here. The issue is: do you know where you're going?
If you do, carry on. I'll let you know later how the trip felt.
Author's Response: Hi Joel, thanks so much for taking the time to read and especially review. I realize how much time it can take and for that I appreciate it. I did have a beta but generally just for flow and some techinical critiques. I have always wanted and needed the opinion of a professional and I'm glad that you took the bullet for the other folks that aren't into MP/J romance.
In response to your advice, and I appreciate every comment you have made:
1. I actually don't post as I write. I let it stew for awhile, however, the entire fic had been sitting for months and was only completed in the past couple of weeks, and of course with the announcement of "Rebirth" got over eager and posted as soon as my beta said "GO." I appreciated objective constructive criticism and you are the first to have done so. Thanks.
2. You are correct, the relationship is the plot and I really didn't think much about external conflict. I wanted it to be a simple story without much angst but certainly drama.
3. The endgame as you probably guessed was MP/J together. Of course that was/is the only thing I glimpsed and basically worked towards getting them there. This is my second fic overall for the Pretender and wasn't quite sure what kind of writer I wanted to become. So I started with what was familiar to me which is romance/drama. I figured that I would get a few fics under my belt and got comfortable with a writing style before I went further into a plot filled fic.
Again, I appreciate the objective technical review of my fic so far and certainly appreciate the time it took you to write your professional opinion.
Thanks Joel!